Manchester and Associates

Pennsylvania Criminal & DUI Defense

Legal Blog

By

← DUI Portal

Remain Silent Or Else

Before deciding to waive your 5th amendment right and talk to the police, contact an experienced attorney from the law offices of Manchester & Associates.

“[Any] lawyer worth [their] salt will tell [their client] in no uncertain terms to make no statement to the police under any circumstances.“

Justice Robert Jackson

The 5th Amendment allows those in police custody to remain silent. Many find this difficult based on the idea that remaining silent when you have nothing to hide makes you seem guilty. However, there are no laws of the United States that allow for a presumption of guilt when you remain silent. You have a right to remain silent, and you should exercise it to its full extent.

While you may think that speaking to the police will help them solve the case, or will allow you to plead your innocence, speaking with police is actually giving them evidence on you that they can and WILL use against you if charges are filed. There is no way that talking to the police will help you: you cannot talk your way out of being arrested. Professor James Duane says in “Don’t Talk to the Police,” the biggest issue with talking with the police is you may accidentally admit wrongdoing and that admission will be difficult to take back later.

Exercise Your Rights.

Remember that police have the power; you are not on an even playing field. The police are allowed to lie to you during an interrogation – they do not need to tell you all of the information they have or whether they are planning to charge you. The police utilize a lot of interrogation tactics, and they are often very successful at getting statements. As you are talking, they are putting together evidence on you, even if it is not clear to you that what you are saying is incriminating. Alec Baldwin recently had first-hand experience with the power of police interrogation after the shooting accident that killed a cinematographer and injured a director on the set of his recent movie. He waived his right to an attorney and talked to the police for hours, answering their questions and providing his own insight into what happened. After that interview, the prosecutor announced plans to charge him with involuntary manslaughter.

If your interrogation leads to charges and you do end up going to trial, it is unlikely that your entire statement will be relayed to the jury. The Rules of Evidence allow police and prosecutors to present the most damaging statements in court, while allowing them to leave out the statements that show your innocence. Professor Duane says, “What you say, can and will be used against you, but it will never be used for you.” Further, if you make contradictory statements, the jury will expect you to explain those contradictions.

Admitting anything to the police will not help your case. Even if entirely innocent and only telling the truth, any information you give to the police will be helpful to them in convicting you. 29% of the 375 people exonerated by the Innocence Project were found to be convicted in part based on a false confession. The cornerstone of our justice system is the presumption of innocence that is afforded to defendants. This presumption of innocence is a burden that has to be overcome by the prosecution. Do not lighten their burden by providing information to the police.

Constitutional rights, including the right to remain silent, exist to protect citizens from the government. The 5th amendment should not just be used by those who did something wrong. Anytime you are asked to speak to the police about an incident that you are involved in, say only one thing: “I want a lawyer from Manchester & Associates.”

By

← DUI Portal

Are Delta 8 And Delta 10 Illegal In Pennsylvania?

The Short Answer Is “Yes”.

Both Delta 8 and Delta 10 are Tetrahydrocannabinols, and both are illegal in Pennsylvania. Even if the Delta 8 or Delta 10 are derived from hemp, and not marijuana, the compounds are illegal because the entire category of Tetrahydrocannabinols, most commonly referred to as THC, is illegal in Pennsylvania. THC is listed as a scheduled substance in Pa. Code 25.72 (b)(3)(xvi). Most people think just Delta 9 is illegal, but legally Delta 8, 9, and 10 are the same. They are all currently illegal.

Many people only think of Delta 9 as being illegal because that is the compound they are taught that gets you “high”. But, legally, Delta 8, 9 and 10 are considered the same substance and all are equally illegal.

Because Delta 9 is the the compound always referred to in the media, people may think that since Delta 8 and Delta 10 can be possessed or sold legally. That is NOT correct. Any merchant that sells products with Delta 8 or 10 in them is committing a felony, and the people who buy those products are committing misdemeanor crimes just by possessing them.

The defenses to charges involving Delta 8 or Delta 10 are numerous, especially when it comes to the testing used to determine the presence of Delta 8 or 10. As a criminal defense lawyer I highly recommend that if you are a store owner you stop selling these products. If you are a consumer of these products, I strongly suggest you no longer purchase them. Until marijuana and THC are legalized in Pennsylvania as they have been in many other states, you will be in danger of criminal charges.

By

← DUI Portal

Can you be arrested in Pennsylvania for Wielding a firearm in self-defense?

Unfortunately, the answer is yes.

Please note that I didn’t say convicted: arrest and conviction are very different things. Arresting is what cops do and it doesn’t mean you are guilty. Neither the police nor Prosecutors decide if you are guilty; that’s up to a jury.


With that said, let us get into why you can be arrested for displaying a firearm in Pennsylvania in self-defense. The answer is simple and disturbing at the same time. With no pun intended, cops, prosecutors, and the public are gun shy. It seems more and more police react first to a situation where a firearm is brandished than they do analyzing the situation. Simply put, it is arrest first and then leave it up to the courts.


When police hear a report of a gun being displayed, they roll out hard and in packs. That’s mostly understandable. There are simply too many instances of people who are bad and use firearms in a dangerous way for them not to take a call of a firearm seriously. We expect them to do that. However, we as citizens also expect them to investigate what actually happened. That seems to be done less and less. In the past three months my firm and I have represented three different people for brandishing their licensed concealed carry pistols that they used to keep from being harmed. In each of the three instances they legitimately used their firearms to actually diffuse the situation to get the aggressor to back down and go away. However, because the bad guys called the cops first, they were charged. Now they had to hire us to protect them after they legitimately protected themselves.


This article isn’t about using firearms in an irresponsible way. That is usually a crime. For instance, if you are driving and someone in front of you starts acting like a jerk and frightening you, you can’t pull out your pistol. This is not good. I had this situation last year. The case ended with a citation and not a misdemeanor or felony conviction, but it was not the right way to use a firearm.


The use of a firearm is deadly force. Deadly force can only be used to avoid death, serious bodily injury, robbery, and rape in PA. Where these situations get grey is when is someone facing serious bodily injury or death without being shot at, stabbed at, robbed, or assaulted sexually? The variations are endless. It is judged upon by the reasonable person standard. Another uncertain term in situations like this but the reasonable person standard analysis is for another post.


There are many appeals court cases where people thought they were justified in brandishing a firearm and using it or just displaying it. In some of them the appeals court overturned the convictions. In others they didn’t. Some of those cases that I read even surprised me that the person wasn’t justified.


Here is the bottom line. If you are in a situation where you feel threatened with serious bodily injury, death, robbery, or rape and you are not the aggressor you will do what you have to. When the situation is over, get to a safe place and call the police. Say you were threatened with whatever occurred and you had to brandish your firearm because you were afraid of one or several of those four things. That is ALL YOU SAY. Once the police arrive, cooperate if they ask you for your firearm but do not talk about what happened. Politely tell them thanks for coming to help you and you want to speak to a lawyer before you give any further statements. Don’t say anything else. Then call a lawyer as soon as possible.

Your lawyer and your freedom and your right to further own a firearm will thank you later.

By

← DUI Portal

Resisting Arrest and DUI Charges in Pennsylvania

Can you be charged and convicted of resisting arrest after you have been stopped for DUI?

Yes, you can.

Here is the statutory language as to resisting arrest in Pennsylvania:


“With the intent of preventing a public servant from effecting a lawful arrest or discharging any other duty, the person creates a substantial risk of bodily injury to the public servant or anyone else, or employs means justifying or requiring substantial force to overcome the resistance.”


That is the legal definition. Now here is how it actually is on the streets with the police. The majority of police officers do not have a lot of patience in DUI stops when it comes to taking you into custody. I know this because I watch a lot of police car videos and we get a lot of DUI cases where resisting arrest is also charged. Once police decide to arrest a driver, if the driver does not quickly turn around, put their arms behind your back, and let them cuff you right away they get very aggressive. That can lead a driver to flinch, asking why they are being treated that way. In normal conversations a person faces the person when they talk. So, in situations where the police officer acts aggressive, drivers tend to turn to face them to ask the officer what is going on. That turn really turns up the heat and then things go downhill quickly.


Now there are times when people do resist, try to run away, and sometimes try to strike the police officer. Obviously, that is not a smart thing to do and is most likely resisting arrest. But many times, when these charges are filed it is simply not complying right away and challenging the officer’s authority that results in resisting arrest. My associates and I love police car videos. They show what really happened and we are often able to get resisting arrest charges dismissed or plead to lesser offenses.


My best advice to people? The street is the police’s turf but the courtroom is ours. No matter how a police officer is acting, the best thing to do is be polite, cooperate and say nothing. If the police want to arrest you, comply with their request and then call us as soon as you can. It is not well known that resisting an illegal arrest can still be a crime. You will not win if you resist. However, if you are polite and comply, no matter how bad the police act or the situation is, you will fare much better. Let the lawyer deal with the police if they were rude or wrong.

By

← DUI Portal

Can You Go To Jail For Driving While Suspended In Philadelphia?

After the first one? You bet.

In this blog I will talk about driving while suspended, 75 Pa.C.S.A. 1543a. I will discuss driving while suspended DUI in another post.

There are many ways to get suspended.

Getting too many points in a short period for different traffic offenses. Driving with suspended registration. Driving without insurance. Getting in a car accident and not paying the judgement. Not responding to a traffic ticket. Yes, you can be suspended for not pleading guilty or not guilty to a ticket. Not paying child support and so on and on.

If you are driving while suspended, about 90 plus percent of the time you will get charged with it.  As I tell my clients all of the time: There is a difference between getting charged and getting convicted. In Pennsylvania your first driving while suspended will only result in a one-year additional suspension. From the second to the fifth time a person is convicted of driving while suspended, a jail sentence is up to the judge. After your sixth and subsequent conviction the minimum is 30 days in jail with a maximum of 6 months. There is no 10 year look back to determine minimum jail time like there is for DUI offenses. It makes no sense that with DUI charges there is a time limit to increase jail time. But as I always say, the law doesn’t make a lot of sense. That is why my firm is so busy.

Now being charged with driving while suspended doesn’t mean you will be convicted. There are many defenses. However, in most cases the police can show a driver is the driver and their license is suspended. In most cases it comes down to mitigating damages. There is a limitless number of legitimate reasons that can be used to do that. That is where experienced lawyers come in and where getting the mitigation together BEFORE court comes to play.

By

← DUI Portal

Is it illegal to drive while on Ambien or another sleeping pill in Pennsylvania?

The answer is: yes, if they impair you. Pennsylvania punishes drug-based DUI offenses the harshest. It does not matter if it is a sleeping pill. Common sleeping medications are Ambien, Lunesta, and Sonata. If you take these, be very careful.


Ambien is a particular nasty sleeping medication that can lead to a condition called somnambulism. Somnambulism is another word for sleepwalking or doing other things while in a sleep state. One of which is sleep driving. That is never a good thing. I have represented clients who have taken Ambien and the next thing they remember is being in a police station after hitting a telephone pole and they do not remember hitting the pole.


Sleeping pill induces drowsiness. It is another drug in the benzodiazepine family. It works by slowing activity in the brain and nervous system. Ambien is used to treat insomnia and sleeping problems.


Sleeping pills like Ambien can have after-effects on people after they wake up. Like a hangover, these can leave people feeling drowsy and lethargic. Sleeping pills in combination with alcohol are a very nasty combination.


I tell my clients and friends that if they take Ambien to have their doctor prescribe something else. Also never mix alcohol with sleeping pills.

By

← DUI Portal

Can taking Xanax lead to a DUI in Pennsylvania?

Yes. People taking Xanax can be pulled over and charged for drugged driving.

Xanax is a brand name of Alprazolam. It is a sedative, from a family of anti-anxiety medications called benzodiazepines. These drugs work by depressing the central nervous system. They make people feel relaxed and calm. They are used as a short-term treatment for anxiety and insomnia (See Medline Plus for further information)


Similar drugs include:

  • Librium
  • Doral
  • Valium
  • Ativan


Taking Xanax and then driving can leave drivers too calm – it can impair a driver’s ability to operate a vehicle safely. Drivers may be too sedated to notice hazards and react to them appropriately.

If you are taking Xanax, you should consider very carefully whether you are able to drive safely before deciding to do so; if you consumed alcohol with Xanax then definitely do not drive. Xanax is a benzodiazepine. It is well known to the scientific community, police, and prosecutors that benzodiazepines enhance the effects of alcohol. In Pennsylvania drug and drug and alcohol combined DUI charges result in punishment in the highest tier.


If you find yourself pulled over for whatever reason, do not tell the police officer you took Xanax . Even if taken in for a blood test. Most people do not know that unless a police officer specifically requests that their blood be tested for Xanax , that it will not be found. The reason for that is the blood must be put into a gas chromatograph specifically set up to test for benzodiazepines. If a police officer only suspects alcohol the lab won’t look for Xanax . Therefore, even if it is present in a driver’s blood it won’t be found and that can possibly avoid enhanced DUI penalties based on the presence of drugs.

When pulled over by a police officer, silence is always golden.

Filed Under: DUI

By

← DUI Portal

How Adderall can lead to a DUI charge in Pennsylvania

Adderall is a stimulant designed primarily to treat ADHD and other attention disorders. Adderall is a combination of the drugs dextroamphetamine and amphetamine. These drugs work to keep someone focused and attentive. Adderall is used to treat ADHD and other attention disorders. Amphetamines are DEA Schedule II (Two) drugs.

Drugs similar to Adderall are:

  • Ritalin
  • Focalin
  • Adzenys
  • Vyvanse


These drugs work by stimulating the central nervous system. As the stimulation begins to fade around six hours on average, it can leave the person taking Adderall feeling tired. It is this tiredness that can lead to poor driving. So people who are on the downside of the pharmacological effects of Adderall can become tired and that is when they get pulled over. It is not the drug causing the poor driving. However, that is not what the police or prosecutors believe.


The best thing you can do if you take Adderall or any other medication for ADHD or other attention related illnesses is to NOT tell a police officer you take it. You do not have to answer an officer if they ask you if you take any medication because the Fifth Amendment to the constitution says so.