• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Manchester and Associates

Manchester and Associates

Pennsylvania Criminal & DUI Defense

  • Home
  • About
    • Brian V. Manchester, Esq.
    • Gregory E. Davidson, Esq.
    • Karen E. Kuebler, Esq.
    • Support Team
  • Practice Areas
    • DUI Defense
    • Drug Crimes
    • Financial Crimes
    • Sex Crimes
    • Violent Crimes
    • Other Criminal Offenses
    • Vehicular Homicide
    • Other Traffic Offenses
    • Juvenile Cases
    • Appeals
    • Civil Asset Forfeiture
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Court Locations
    • Bail Bondsmen
    • Criminal Law
    • Downloads
  • FAQs
  • Client Testimonials
  • Contact Us

November 10, 2020 By admin

Were My Rights Violated Because I Was Not Read My Rights?

The first thing people need to understand is that you are not legally obligated to do a whole lot at a traffic stop. You should be cordial and respectful with the officer and you want to comply with their commands. If they ask you to turn the car off or get out of the vehicle then comply and do that. However, your only legal duty in the state of Pennsylvania is to provide your license, registration, and proof of insurance. You do not have to say or provide anything else. If the police are asking you “Why did I pull you over,” you do not have to answer that. You don’t have to speculate on what you may or may not have been doing that was illegal. This also goes to the Field Sobriety Tests that offiers may ask you to perform. You can choose to decline these tests. There are a various numbers of reasons why you might decline to do those tests. However, if the officer asks you to give a breath or blood test, there are ramifications for declining or refusing to take those tests.

There are three different levels of custody. Each level bring new rights and protections for you. Just because you were pulled over and the officer is asking you questions does not mean you have to be “Mirandized” or “read your rights”.

The lowest level is a “Mere Encounter” is where you happen to come into contact with a police officer on the street or driving down the road. This is simply a mere encounter with the officer; the officer was not looking for you, you both just happened to be there at the same time. Basically, your only obligation here to the officer is if they ask for identification, you must provide it. Other than that, you do not have to do anything else for the officer or answer any of their questions.

The next level is an “Investigatory Detention”. This is your typical traffic stop where you are pulled over. The officer has some reasonable belief that you may have committed some type of offense. They can legally briefly detain you to investigate that offense. This gives them a little bit broader powers to detain you for a period of time to determine whether or not a law has been violated. They are allowed to investigate what law they believe you broke until they determine whether they have enough evidence to determine whether a crime has been committed. At that point, you are detained, but your rights have not fully kicked in at this point. Many individuals get “investigative detention” confused with the next level, which is called “custodial detention.” While it is true that you are being detained with “investigative detention,” it’s only for investigative purposes. At this level the officer does not have to “mirandize” or “read you your rights” and you do not have to answer any questions.

The highest level is “Custodial Detention.” This is the equivalent of a full blown arrest. You are not free to leave and the officers at this level must read you your rights before they start to question you. In other wards now you need to be “Mirandized”. What this means is that you can be in custodial detention and not receive you Miranda Rights as long as the police are not asking you questions about the case. Once the officers start interrogating you, then your rights apply and they must notify you that you have the right to remain silent and the right to an attorney. In addition at this level you are not required to answer any of their questions.

Regardless of whether or not you were “Mirandized” or “read your rights” you always have the option and right to remain silent and not answer any questions asked by the police.

Filed Under: DUI Portal

Primary Sidebar

  • Types of DUI
    • DUI Crimes
    • Alcohol DUI Charges
    • Drug DUI
    • Aggravated Assault by Vehicle
    • Aggravated Assault While DUI
    • Pennsylvania Ignition Interlock Limited License
    • Driving without a license
    • Driving with a Suspended License (DUI related)
    • Driving with a Suspended License (Not DUI related)
    • Driving Under the Influence of Controlled Substances
    • Issues With Blood Testing
    • I am under 21 and received DUI charges
    • Getting a DUI with children in the vehicle
    • Medical Marijuana and DUI in Pennsylvania
    • Ignition Interlock for Work Vehicles
      • Aggravated Assault By Vehicle While DUI
  • DUI Education
    • Will I lose my license if I am convicted of a DUI in Pennsylvania?
    • What are Field Sobriety Tests?
    • Can Someone Be Charged With More Than One DUI For The Same Incident?
    • How Does A DUI Affect A Commercial Driver’s License (CDL)?
    • Does PA have special Programs for DUI Offenders?
    • Should I Enter A Treatment Program?
    • Should I take the ARD Program for my DUI?
    • Why was I charged with a DUI when I was not driving?
    • What Should I Do If Asked To Take A BAC (Blood Alcohol Content) Test?
    • What Happens When I Get A DUI With An Out Of State License?
    • Were My Rights Violated Because I Was Not Read My Rights?
    • How Long Will A Conviction for DUI Stay on my Criminal Record?
    • Will a conviction for a DUI in another state show up on my record in Pennsylvania?
    • Are There Criminal Consequences for Refusing A Blood Test?
    • Are There Criminal Consequences for Refusing A Breath Test?
    • Are There Criminal Consequences for Refusing A Blood Test After the Police Get A Search Warrant for My Blood?
    • How do I find the best DUI Lawyer in Pennsylvania?
    • My son or daughter is a juvenile and has been charged with a DUI. What Can happen to them?
    • How much will a DUI cost me?
    • Is a DWI the same as DUI?
    • Can I be convicted of a DUI with my use of medical Marijuana?
    • Can I be convicted of a DUI if I am taking prescription drugs?
    • Can I represent myself at a preliminary hearing for a DUI?
    • Is a DUI a Felony in Pennsylvania?
    • Why am I charged with careless driving and DUI?
    • Can I be forced to take a breath test?
    • Can I be forced to take a blood test?
    • Can I be charged with a crime if I refuse a chemical test?
    • Can I get sentenced to house arrest if I am convicted of a DUI?
    • Will a DUI Conviction affect my professional license?
    • Can I Own A Gun If I Am Convicted Of A DUI?
    • Will a DUI conviction affect my concealed carry permit?
    • Will I Lose my Gun Rights if I am on ARD for a DUI?
    • Can I Fight Losing my License for a DUI Conviction?
    • What Happens to my Driver’s License if I Refuse a Chemical Test (blood test or breath test)?
    • What Happens if I am convicted of a DUI, but I am not from Pennsylvania?
  • DUI News
    • Anatomy Of A Successful Dismissal Of A DUI & Vehicular Homicide While DUI Charge
    • Landmark Change in How Title IX Violations are Handled
    • Synthetic Marijuana Victory
    • Bradford County DUI Appeal Victory
  • County by County DUI
    • Bedford County
    • Blair County
    • Bradford County
    • Cambria County
    • Cameron County
    • Centre County
    • Clarion County
    • Clearfield County
    • Clinton County
    • Columbia County
    • Elk County
    • Huntingdon County
    • Jefferson County
    • Juniata County
    • Lycoming County
    • McKean County
    • Mifflin County
    • Montour County
    • Northumberland County
    • Perry County
    • Potter County
    • Snyder County
    • Somerset County
    • Sullivan County
    • Tioga County
    • Union County

Footer

Manchester and Associates

124 West Bishop Street
Bellefonte, PA, 16823

1-(800)-243-4878
Email Us Here

Additional Information

Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Legal Disclaimer

Copyright © 2021 Manchester and Associates - PA. All rights reserved.
Call Us Now